In Related News, The Sky Is Blue

by Bengals

Well, I think we all saw this coming. Joe Reedy of The Cincinnati Enquirer reports that the Andre Smith holdout doesn’t appear to have an end in sight. The problem? The Bengals want to pay Smith less than what the seventh pick in the draft, Darrius Heyward-Bey, got from the Raiders.

According to Reedy, the Bengals have offered $33 million, $5.25 million less than what Bey received. If this is true (and there’s no reason to believe it isn’t), the Bengals have reached another penny-pinching low. I know at this point I should never be surprised by the miserly nature of Mike Brown and his cohorts, but I am exasperated, infuriated and outraged (that sounded like something Johnny Cochran would have said. Impressive).

The slotting system for draft picks is almost universally accepted. The first pick gets the most money, the second gets more than the third and so on. The Bengals’ attempt to circumvent this system is a lot like going to the grocery store, grabbing a loaf of bread marked for a $1 and then telling the cashier that you won’t pay a penny more than 50-cents for it. Guess what? In the grocery store, you ain’t getting that loaf of bread.

Which brings us back to this Andre Smith fiasco. Michael Crabtree looks like an idiot for trying to get more money that what his draft spot dictates. Sorry Mike, that’s not the way things work. The 10th pick gets paid somewhere between what the 9th and 11th make. It’s always been that way.

And now the Bengals are trying to pull the same shenanigans. It’s precisely this same type of thing that makes them the laughinstock of the league. I usally defend them far beyond reasonable bounds, but I can’t even come close on this one. The Bengals front office personnel are embarrassing themselves right now. The team constantly blabs about its commitment to winning and then it pulls this low-rent, cheapskate act with a player that absolutely needs to be in camp sweating off his moobs (man + boobs).

I’m disgusted. Rant over.

 

News:  The Bengals held a scrimmage tonight with the offense getting the best of the defense. The running backs in particular looked good acccording to Geoff Hobson of Bengals.com, with James Johnson, Cedric Benson and Brian Leonard making some nice plays. Bernard Scott sat out with a shoulder problem. The logjam at running back is going to be interesting to watch because Johnson always seems to make the most of his opportunities and Scott has reportedly drawn comparisons to Titans running back Chris Johnson by some teammates (hopefully,  they were not under the influence when they said this). I believe the team usually only keeps three tailbacks on the roster, but may need to get creative this season to hold onto its talent.

Comments
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Step back from the edge, Nate. I had the same initial reaction, but upon re-reading the story, it sounds like the $33 million offer probably preceeded the Heyward-Bey deal. Per Reedy, the last time two sides were in contact was Monday, which would have been the 3rd. DHB was signed July 30.

I suspect the Bengals made the $33 million offer to Smith in late July, and that number subsequently got blowed up by the Raiders.

All that said, no way Smith is going to sign for less than DHB. So now all they can do is hold off caving in until the last minute, which allows them to keep his money in the bank earning interest for them as long as possible. Normally I would get upset about that since it means Smith misses camp just so Mikey can make a few more pennies, but AC is doing fine at RT, so there should be plenty of time for Smith to get up to speed.

To do what? To agree to overpay Smith? Now that's a thought.

They're offering him what they think he's worth. Everybody knows DHB and Sanchez are overpaid so the slotting argument makes no sense.

Mike Brown is that you?

Hire a GM ass.

Sorry, I think it's a good strategic move. When arguing the rookie cap, players suggest it's the owner's fault for offering so much. Ok, so MB decides to offer what he think the guy is worth versus being dictated to by what five and seven do. Sanchez is overpaid as is DHB, so why should our hand be forced by what they paid their folks? In the end, we have AC who, remember, blanked Harrison when we played the Steelers. He doesn't suck. I bet the owners think it's a ballsy move and if it works, it will open the door for more flexibility in the future for negotiating with rookies.