1. Joe Montana (San Fransisco 49ers/Kansas City Chiefs)
There is no real debate here. Joe Montana is the greatest quarterback of all time. He went 4-0 in the Super Bowl, including 2 wins against our beloved Bengals, and they weren’t even close for the most part. He never lost the Super Bowl, which included a 55-10 decimation against the Elway-led Denver Broncos. Montana was the master of the comeback victory, and one of those comebacks came in the Super Bowl against, well, us. He would retire with the highest QB rating ever at 92.8.
Here are my honorable mentions: