The Cincinnati Bengals made a calculated gamble this season. After years of defensive ineptitude kept them out of the playoffs for three consecutive seasons, they went ahead and made big splashes in the offseason. The Dexter Lawrence trade, as well as the signing of Bryan Cook and Boye Mafe have all greatly elevated the Bengals' defense.
However, the Bengals made a bold decision to not bolster their linebacker unit after last season. The rookie duo of Demetrius Knight Jr. and Barrett Carter were two of the worst-performing players on the worst defense in the NFL last season. Instead of getting linebacker help this offseason, though, the front office placed their bets on the idea that both Knight and Carter would significantly improve this season. They doubled down on that decision at the trade deadline, refusing to trade for a linebacker.
It took them a while, but both Knight and Carter are starting to round into form and become passable linebackers at worse, and game changers when they're at their very best.
Demetrius Knight Jr and Barrett Carter's vast improvement is a key reason for the Bengals' defensive resurgence
Linebacker might be the hardest defensive position for a rookie to pick up in the NFL. They're tasked with guarding the short and intermediate areas of the field, where there's a ton going on from the offense. That, coupled with their responsibilities in the run game, makes it a challenging position to learn.
We saw exactly how hard that transition was last season. Knight and Carter were put in an impossible scenario, tasked with plugging up the holes on a defense that was doing its best Swiss cheese cosplay. Both Bengals' linebackers were constantly out of position, both in the run and the pass game, and their tackling woes only compounded their defensive issues.
The Bengals were hoping that by having a better front four and a better secondary, both Knight and Carter would have less to worry about. And to an extent, we are starting to see both players improve significantly in certain areas.
Knight has been an absolute beast in the run game this season. He's quick on the trigger and is great at just sealing the gaps pried open by the monstrous defensive line. His tackling has also greatly improved, as he's making sure to keep a nice solid base and wrapping up opposing running backs quickly. He's a big reason why the Bengals have been solid against the run this year.
Meanwhile, Carter has developed nicely as a solid coverage linebacker, filling the void left by Logan Wilson a few years ago. He's been great at both identifying who he needs to pick up and breaking up passes. He already has nine passes defended and two interceptions on the year, and has also forced two fumbles.
However, both Carter and Knight have been pretty one-dimensional to start the year. Knight's peripheral vision is lacking at times, allowing easy completions to the hook zones he should be responsible for. Carter's vision against the run isn't quite like Knight's, as he is still taking poor angles and running straight into the blockers.
Against the Steelers, though, both linebackers showed marked improvement in their weaknesses while keeping their core strengths. Knight was critical in slowing down Jaylen Warren, but he was also pretty good in coverage, nearly picking off a pass. Carter was able to slow down Pittsburgh's short passing game, but he also filled his role well in run defense and was able to make crucial tackles on his side of the ball.
The result was the most complete defensive performance the Bengals have put forward this season. Pittsburgh's two touchdowns in the game came in garbage time, where Cincinnati was more concerned with running out the clock instead of completely stopping the Steelers. Even in garbage time, Knight and Carter were still doing their jobs well.
This game should be an encouraging sign for the Bengals moving forward. Now that we've seen what a complete Bengals defense looks like, we know this team can legitimately go all the way.
