Skip to main content

Live by the sword, die by the sword: Amarius Mims and Shemar Stewart

The Bengals rolled the dice in two similar situations. It worked once. It didn't work the second time.
ByJason Garrison
Nov 8, 2026; Madrid, ESP;  Cincinnati Bengals offensive tackle Amarius Mims (71) in action against the Atlanta Falcons during the fourth quarter at Bernabeu Stadium.  Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images
Nov 8, 2026; Madrid, ESP; Cincinnati Bengals offensive tackle Amarius Mims (71) in action against the Atlanta Falcons during the fourth quarter at Bernabeu Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Cincinnati Bengals, after six years of allowing Joe Burrow to consistently be one of the most-hit quarterbacks in the league, finally put together a good offensive line. They've been able to keep Burrow upright, and they have been headlined by right tackle Amarius Mims, who is playing at an All-Pro level so far in 2026.

Mims has only allowed one sack and six total pressures on 381 pass-blocking snaps, per PFF, and his 79.9 pass-blocking grade is second among tackles who have taken 80% of the snaps. He and Orolando Brown Jr have developed into two bookend tackles--very, very big bookend tackles--and have given Burrow time to put up the MVP numbers he has so far this season.

What was the big knock on Mims coming out of college? It was the fact he only started in eight games while at Georgia. Of course he was a physical freak and the potential was there, but there was a reason he was available when the Bengals went on the clock at No. 18 when four tackles were selected before him. Had those four teams known what Mims would be in 2026, you better believe they would have run to the podium to submit his name.

It worked out for the Bengals.

The very next year, the Bengals went on the clock at No. 17. With that selection they rolled the dice on another guy who had some red flags, but was a physical freak. Of course I'm talking about edge rusher Shemar Stewart, who was only able to accrue 4.5 sacks in three seasons at Texas A&M.

Of course, lack of production and lack of experience aren't exactly the same thing--I'm very much aware I'm comparing apples and oranges here. However, the similarities can't be ignored. Both Mims and Stewart are physical specimens, and both had some red flags the front office and coaching staff chose to ignore. It's safe to say the Bengals could have made a safer pick each time, and while it's really early, it might also be safe to say it burned them the second time around.

Stewart, so far, has been exactly what many feared he would be--a lot of potential that can't put it together on the field. Things have gotten so bad in his second season with the team that he was a healthy scratch in Week 7 against the Baltimore Ravens, a division rival. Not only that, but when Cashius Howell was placed on IR, the team attempted--and failed--to trade for Eagles edge rusher Arnold Ebiketie, showing Stewart exactly how much faith they have in him moving forward.

Of course there's time for Stewart to right the ship, but what we're seeing from him right now is really worrisome. The Bengals, for their part, may have learned their lesson from his selection, though.

While they didn't have a first-round pick in 2026 to make up for it--they traded that to the Giants in exchange for Dexter Lawrence--they did use their first pick of the draft on fellow Texas A&M pass rusher Howell, who is kind of the anti-Stewart.

Not only is he shorter and lighter than the typical 4-3 edge rushers the Bengals covet early in the draft, but he was productive in college. He was responsible for 27 total sacks in his college career, and he ended that career with an 11.5-sack season for the Aggies.

We're halfway through the season, and the Bengals are in firm control of their destiny moving forward. The division title and a first-round bye are legitimate targets, and the Bengals are among a few teams considered true contenders.

Mims is very much to thank for so much of the success the team has found so far.

Stewart, not so much.

Add us as a preferred source on Google